Thought for Thursday – Doing Your Research

(cross-posted at The Blue Door)


My seniors are (or, rather, should be) engaged in a research project that will allow them to write an analysis paper on The Handmaid’s Tale.  Their purpose is to link Atwood’s dystopian novel to current (or recent) events, whether here or in other countries, in meaningful and logical ways.  Given what’s happening in politics lately, I thought it was a paper that could pretty much write itself.  I don’t want it to write itself, though, so I’ve been spending some time with the kids going over how to do ethical research.

The problem when I was a kid was finding information – we needed to be taught where to look for the things we needed to know.  The problem for my students (and my children) is finding good information – there is so much that is so readily available (and is so often ridiculously unreliable), that teaching kids how to sift through the sketchy stuff to find valid sources is a priority in my teaching about research.

I was thinking about this tonight when I got into it with a facebook friend about the factual validity of something that was posted on her wall.  On the surface it was no big deal – it was a clearly partisan bit of sarcasm and anger and was clearly intended as such – but it sparked a conversation about the veracity of the information that we bounce around the internet.

One of the things that I need – not just want, but need – for my students to understand is how desperately vital it is that they learn to think critically about the things that get presented to them as fact.  It seems to me that we’ve gotten to a point (or, perhaps it has always been thus and I’m just noticing it more) where it’s become accepted practice to pick and choose the details one wants from a given set of information so that one can prove whatever point one is trying to forward.  It doesn’t matter that the whole of the set indicates something entirely contrary to what is being reported – as long as items A and B support a particular viewpoint, items C through Z can be conveniently downplayed (or outright ignored).

Facts can be very inconvenient things.  They can challenge a previously held belief, they can force a reevaluation of a prejudice, and they can seriously hinder an argument.  Facts can compel us to rethink the way we see ourselves and can rattle what we think of as foundational beliefs.  That can be scary; so scary that a lot of people are just as happy to not do it at all.

It’s important to me that my students not be intimidated by the idea that the facts might force them to rethink the way they see the world – or the way they see themselves.  It can be profoundly uncomfortable – threatening and existentially terrifying, even – to have one’s thesis (or world view) refuted by the facts, but my hope is that I can raise my students to understand that the mark of a strong and mature intellect is being able to adjust one’s thinking when the evidence indicates that an adjustment is necessary.



Filed under about writing, analysis, compassion and cooperation, concerns, critical thinking, ethics, Literature, out in the real world, politics, rhetoric, self-analysis, Teaching

5 responses to “Thought for Thursday – Doing Your Research

  1. bnr

    Thinking critically is becoming a lost art. We need to discuss it continually at all grade levels. I teach 6th grade, some classes struggle with it more htan others. It scares me to think that I am going to be taken care of by people who can’t think independently, but rely on what they are told. Thank you for teaching them to think…

  2. PT

    I work in a community college and the students struggle with this so mightily. It’s…depressing. (But a teachable moment!!! Ha). One thing the professors do is show the students how to use scholarly/otherwise reputable databases, to never “just Google it”–in a way, the evaluating-the-“facts” skills begins with considering the source.

  3. Kabodkin

    I teach art in an inner city school. This was my question 11 years ago when I began. Teaching children to have higher thinking skills, “evaluating” skills seems to be getting more and more difficult and rare. I recently am taking classes to get my “Library” which is now called “Media Specialist” endorsement. Do you have a good “media specialist” on staff at your school? This could be your key. When I finish these classes I will have some tools on how to weed through the www bull and get to the good stuff. If you do not have anyone – by the way I have yet to meet a good “media specialist” in my neck of the woods – begin to look at Web 2.0 and 3.0 tools and how they can help. Thinking skills are hard to teach but students do love to grab on to them because they take ownership of their information.

  4. Donna

    Mrs. Chili,
    I would suggest modeling to your students with a couple examples–show on overhead, smartboard, a topic, google research, and examine facts and research found. Continue with class discussion, finalize with teacher modeling about what may be ambiguous, sketchy, non-factual, etc. Let them discuss and decide for the majority. Excellent post topic!

  5. scott

    This is such a frustrating issue for me as well. I keep in mind that my students have been living in a completely different world than I did 20+ years ago. Information for them now is quick and instantaneous and comes from a myriad of sources. For me, you opened a book and didn’t question the reliability of the source because THAT was the source. You really have to adjust your teaching to accommodate the change in technology. Thank you for bringing up this issue.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s